You are in Phoenix. We also have a Tucson site.

You are in Phoenix. We also have a Tucson site.

You are in Phoenix. We also have a Tucson site.

PEX vs Copper Tubing: Which Option is Right for Your Plumbing Needs?


Copper Tubbing

When it comes to plumbing your home, the choice between PEX and copper tubing can feel overwhelming, but it doesn't have to be!

This comprehensive guide will walk you through the advantages and drawbacks of both materials, helping you make an informed decision. From installation ease and environmental impact to cost considerations and durability, we cover everything you need to know. Let's dive in!

Key Takeaways

1. Learn whether PEX pipes or Copper tubing is more durable and which one is better suited for your climate.

2. Understand the drawbacks and benefits of PEX plastic and copper pipes.

3. Understand how both pipe materials work with your existing plumbing system.

Understanding Your Options: Copper vs PEX

Understanding the options available when choosing the right pipe material for your plumbing system is essential! Copper and PEX pipes are two popular choices, each with advantages and disadvantages. Let's get a brief overview of both!

 If you're still questioning what type of pipe material is correct, it's always helpful to talk to a local plumber for advice.

History of PEX and Copper Tubing

Understanding the history of PEX and copper tubing can give valuable insights into why these materials have become staples in modern plumbing systems.

  • Copper pipes: Copper replaced galvanized pipes in the early 20th century. By the 1970s, copper plumbing and multiple pipe materials had become the standard for homes and buildings and have been in modern systems ever since.

  • PEX: PEX, or cross-linked polyethylene, was introduced in Europe in the mid-20th century as a flexible and cost-effective alternative to rigid piping and as an alternative to PVC pipes. PEX pipe became popular in the early 2000s because of its ease of installation and freeze resistance.

Today, both PEX and copper are popular choices for water supply lines. Copper is trusted for its history and reliability, and PEX is for its flexibility and cost.

Lifespan of PEX and Copper Tubing

When planning your plumbing project, it's crucial to consider the long-term needs and durability of the materials you choose. Learn a bit more about the lifespan of these materials!

  • Copper Pipes: Last longer than PEX, 50 to 70 years if maintained properly, and often need fewer replacements and repairs. Copper is less prone to UV damage and pest issues compared to PEX.

  • PEX Pipes: 25 to 50-year lifespan, more susceptible to extreme temperatures and certain chemicals. PEX pipes are less durable than copper pipes due to their materials and susceptibility to damage from extreme temperatures, chemicals, and everyday wear and tear. They are also vulnerable to UV rays and rodents. PEX can expand without bursting in freezing conditions, a significant advantage in colder climates.

PEX and copper pipes can provide reliable service when installed and maintained correctly for many years. If you're uncertain about which material best fits your plumbing project, consulting with a professional plumber can help you make an informed decision tailored to your specific needs.

Installation of Both Pipe Materials

The installation and maintenance of copper pipes and PEX pipes differ significantly.

  • Copper Pipes: Require more upfront work. They must be cut and welded to fit specific lengths and connections, a process that can be time-consuming and labor-intensive and often requires the expertise of a professional plumber.

  • PEX Pipes: On the other hand, PEX pipes tend to be more flexible and easily installed without welding or cutting, making them a more DIY-friendly option. However, PEX pipes require specialized tools, such as crimp rings and cinch clamps, to connect them to fittings. This can add to the initial setup cost but remains more straightforward than the labor-intensive process of installing copper pipes.

Health and Safety of Water Pipes

Health and safety are essential when choosing plumbing materials. Studies show that PEX pipes can leach certain chemicals into drinking water; some are toxic but not cancer-causing.

  • Copper Pipes: Do not have chemical leaching issues, so they are safer for many homeowners. Although concerns exist, there is no concrete evidence that PEX tubing leaches harmful chemicals, and regulatory bodies require flushing PEX systems to mitigate risks.

  • PEX: These pipes cause a gasoline-like odor in water due to solvent leaching. While the long-term effect on water quality is unknown, it’s something to consider. Plasticizers are not added to PEX tubing, so there are fewer contaminants.

Understanding the health and safety of water pipes is crucial. Being informed about your plumbing and pipes will help you be a confident homeowner. Contact a trusted plumbing professional to ask more questions about your pipes' health and safety.

Durability and Performance

Durability and performance are important when choosing between PEX and copper pipes.

  • Copper pipes are durable but prone to corrosion, which can lead to leaks over time. They can freeze and burst in extreme cold and develop pinhole leaks due to age, stress and poor water quality, which can cause copper pipes to freeze.

  • PEX's high flexibility allows it to expand under pressure from freezing water, reducing the risk of bursting and making it suitable for cold climates. PEX is resistant to corrosion and electrolysis, which are common issues in copper piping. Some types of PEX also resist chlorine and UV exposure, making PEX a durable and versatile option for modern plumbing systems.

Both PEX and copper pipes offer distinct durability and performance benefits, with copper providing long-term resilience against corrosion and PEX excelling in flexibility and resistance to freezing, making each suitable for different plumbing needs.

Environmental Impact

The environmental impact of copper pipes and PEX pipes is an important consideration.

  • Copper pipes are recyclable, making them a more sustainable option in the long run. However, the manufacturing process can be energy-intensive and produce waste. 

  • PEX pipes, on the other hand, are made from a non-toxic and recyclable material. However, the production process of PEX pipes can also produce waste, and the pipes themselves cannot be recycled in the same way as copper pipes. While PEX has a smaller environmental footprint during production, copper’s recyclability offers long-term ecological benefits.

The environmental impact of plumbing materials is vital to consider, with copper pipes being recyclable and more long-term sustainable. In contrast, PEX pipes have a smaller production footprint but are not as easily recycled.

Cost Comparison

When budgeting for your plumbing project, weighing the initial expenses against long-term savings is essential, as the cost dynamics between PEX and copper pipes can significantly influence your decision.

  • Copper pipes are generally more expensive than PEX pipes, especially regarding labor costs. Despite the higher initial cost, copper pipes may offer better value over time due to their durability and longevity.

  • PEX pipes can add up quickly, especially if you need to purchase specialized tools and fittings. Conversely, PEX pipes are more budget-friendly upfront, particularly for DIY projects.

The cost of copper pipes and PEX pipes varies significantly. Contact a local plumbing expert near you to get a complete bid for your plumbing project!

Common Issues and Solutions

Just like any other materials, both PEX and copper pipes come with their own set of common challenges. Let's chat more about the issues so you know what to look for and plan for!

  • Copper Pipes: Can develop pinhole leaks due to water chemistry and aging. Regular inspections and proper installation techniques can help mitigate these issues for PEX and copper piping.

  • PEX Pipes: Over time, UV light exposure can cause brittleness. Improper installation can cause leaks at connections, and temperature extremes can cause expansion and contraction, creating stress points that may eventually lead to leaks. PEX maintenance is more straightforward and less invasive than copper maintenance, which often requires cutting through walls for access.

Regular inspections and maintenance are key to addressing potential issues before they become significant problems.

Compatibility with Existing Plumbing Systems

If you're asking, "How do these plumbing materials fit in with my existing plumbing system?" you're asking the right questions! It's essential to understand how future plumbing projects work with your home!

  • Copper Pipes: To connect copper piping to a water heater, it's recommended to use at least 18 inches of copper to ensure safety and efficiency, particularly with hot water applications. This ensures that the system remains effective and minimizes any potential heat-related risks.

  • PEX Pipes: Connecting PEX tubing to existing copper or galvanized plumbing systems requires fittings and special tools. Despite the need for these tools, the process is generally straightforward, allowing PEX to be integrated with minimal modifications. PEX plumbing systems often include a manifold for individual water shutoffs, offering convenience for homeowners looking to upgrade without significant disruption.

Summary: Choosing the Right Material

Choosing the right pipe material for your plumbing system depends on several factors, including budget, project size, existing plumbing materials, and personal preference.

  • Copper pipes are an excellent choice for larger projects or homes that demand a robust and enduring plumbing system. They are particularly suitable for installations where the plumbing is exposed to sunlight or outdoor elements, as copper is less susceptible to UV damage than PEX. If you're planning a plumbing project requiring high reliability and minimal maintenance over the years, copper pipes are the way to go. For those with existing copper plumbing systems, sticking with copper can simplify compatibility and reduce the need for additional fittings or adapters.

  • PEX pipes are an excellent choice for plumbing projects that require flexibility and ease of installation, especially for smaller or DIY-friendly projects. They are particularly beneficial in homes where the plumbing needs to navigate through tight spaces or around obstacles, as their flexibility allows for fewer connections and fittings. PEX is also suitable for projects in colder climates because it can expand without bursting in freezing conditions. Additionally, PEX is ideal for those looking for a cost-effective solution, as it generally involves lower initial expenses than copper pipes.

Ultimately, it’s essential to consult with a professional plumber to determine the best pipe material for your specific needs. They can provide expert advice tailored to your home’s plumbing requirements, ensuring you make an informed decision that balances cost, durability, and ease of installation.

Interested in Upgrading Your Plumbing System?

Now that you know more about copper and PEX pipes, you may feel ready to tackle your plumbing project!

At Parker & Sons, our team of experienced plumbers are ready to help. Whether you have more questions about pipes or are ready to get a free quote, give us a call today!

Frequently Asked Questions

Can PEX be used for hot water applications?

PEX can be used for hot water applications. Include 18 inches of copper piping between the water heater and the PEX. This way, you ensure a safe and efficient setup!

What are the potential health concerns with PEX?

There are concerns that PEX pipes can leach chemicals into drinking water, which might impact taste and smell. However, there's no solid proof that these leachates are harmful.

How does the installation of PEX compare to copper?

PEX is easier and faster to install than copper, as it needs fewer tools and skips the cutting and welding steps. This makes it a fantastic choice for DIY enthusiasts!

Which material is more environmentally friendly, PEX or copper?

PEX is generally more environmentally friendly during production due to its smaller footprint, but copper wins in recyclability. It depends on which aspect you prioritize!

Are there any common issues with PEX or copper pipes?

Absolutely! PEX pipes can become brittle with UV exposure and expand or contract with temperature changes, while copper pipes can develop pinhole leaks from water chemistry and aging. Regular inspections and proper installation are key to avoiding these issues.

Related Reading